Are You Suffering from Low Teacher Morale?

Low teacher morale is nothing new, but teacher burnout which is the extreme version of low morale seems to be on the rise. Teacher morale has been in the tank for years, and the pressures of arbitrary accountability measures and an unfathomable emphasis on testing at the expense of authentic teaching and learning are taking a huge toll on teachers.

Those who are experiencing the symptoms of teacher burnout are also experiencing the dread of having to stay in a profession they no longer love for another 15 or 20 years (or longer).

Some teachers feel stuck because of the promise of their pensions at the end of their career, but even then, it hardly seems worth the sacrifice at times. Teachers who are experiencing burnout are often irritable, sad, or even depressed. They sometimes find themselves taking it out on their kids, which is why I want to counsel them out of the classroom before they do harm to a child’s self-esteem forever. The frustrated roll of a teacher’s eyes, the disdain in a teacher’s voice, a reprimand that is harshly delivered can leave some children with emotional scars that stay with them forever.

Teachers don’t deserve to be stuck in jobs they no longer love, and kids don’t deserve to be stuck with a teacher who doesn’t want to be with them.

Photo by Shutterstock

Photo by Shutterstock

If you are a burned out teacher or if you are suffering from rock-bottom morale, then you may be thinking it is time to go. The problem is where can you go? With so many years in the classroom and degrees in education or educational leadership or curriculum and instruction, where does one go to plug in their talents?

The answer is that as the economy is improving, the options for teachers improve every day. Recruiters tell me that they love to help teachers land new jobs because employers love teachers.

Teachers are smart, they have a great work ethic, they are eager to learn, and they want to be successful.

The fact is that you don’t necessarily have to leave teaching if you are just unhappy with your current situation. Perhaps you have a bullying principal…I hear lots of stories about those folks. Because they are under so much pressure themselves, many principals take it out on their teachers the way some bullying teachers take it out on their students. Maybe you don’t have to leave teaching; you just need a new school or a different school district.

I often talk with teachers who are unhappy, but when I ask them what they have done about, the usual response is “Nothing yet.” My question is “What are you waiting for?”

Photo by Depositphotos

Here is what I think the issue is. Because of the way the school year usually runs, it is easy to get stuck and go from year to year hoping that next year will be better. I always thought that one of the great things about being a teacher was that we could come to the end of a school year and have a summer to recover. If it was a particularly rough school year, you could sigh in relief when it was over and hope that next year would be better. Maybe you would have an easier assignment, or perhaps other factors would weigh in and you would just have an easier year. The truth is that for most of us, the years ebb and flow…some are good, some not so much.

You hang in there because you also get the vacation breaks just when you need them most.

People who don’t teach won’t get this, I suspect, but if you are a teacher, you will. The school year generally starts in August or September, depending on your geographic location. Regardless of the location, however, the back-to-school year excitement is palpable. The first day of a school is the best! Everyone and everything is fresh and new, and students and teachers alike are eager to get a new school year started.

Back to School

This sense of “newness” wears off pretty quickly, however. Before the month of September is over, depending on what is happening in your classroom, you as a teacher may already be looking forward to Thanksgiving break. Yikes!

Between Thanksgiving and the Winter Break, you think you can probably do just about anything, so you hang in there. With the Winter Break, you get a few days to relax and decompress. You realize that things are tough, but you renew your hope and faith that the rest of the year will go well as you ring in a new year. By mid-February, you may be totally exhausted, though. You haven’t had a decent break since the Winter Break, and no breaks are in sight until Spring Break. You white-knuckle it until then, and then you start to look forward to the end of the year.

The hardest part of the year is ahead of you because after Spring Break is “Testing Season.”

During the spring testing season, everyone must be tested and re-tested and tested again to make sure everyone can pass the BIG test at the end of the year. For your kids and you, the pressure is on. You must get the kids ready for their tests because your job is on the line if they don’t do well. The feeling of stress begins to permeate the entire school. Everyone feels the burden of needing to do well on their tests. There are after school tutoring sessions and even school rallies…anything to motivate the kids to do well on their tests.

The school year finally comes to an end. You take a big sigh of relief. Once the tests are behind you, you can start to anticipate the end of the year and a sense of anticipation returns. You start to look forward to whatever your summer break holds for you. You can do anything to get to the end of the year, after all, and once the last student is gone, and the room has been packed up for the summer.

You can move on to your summer plans.

Summer break!

By July, regardless of the kind of year you had before, you begin to feel a certain anticipation about the new year which is just around the corner. You start scouting out deals on school supplies and cool new things you can use to decorate your room.

I worked with teachers who would start to come back to school two weeks before the first work day to start getting their room set up.

They came in on their vacation days to put up all their bulletin boards, get the textbooks ready, put names on all of the cubbies, and just generally “nest” before the work week officially started. There are too many meetings to attend and too many interruptions to get that work done once their contract kicked in. As a result, who knows about many hours of free work the district benefits from because teachers are so dedicated? That is the cycle I observed in my 33 years in the K-12 sector, however,and regardless of the school that I served, I saw the same thing time after time, year after year.

Have I described the typical school year for you?

There may be some variations, but the fact is that for many teachers, what I have just described is their life, and I happen to believe it helps to contribute to teachers feeling stuck. They are caught in a perpetual cycle of anticipation…either anticipation of a new year or anticipation of it all being over.

The pain of their current situation gets muddled with their hope that things will be better next year. And truthfully, if next year is better, it is easy to get lulled into thinking that this isn’t so bad after all. The pay is not great, but at least it provides a steady income. The benefits could be better, but at least you have benefits. Your principal may be awful, but the fact is that principals come and go. Maybe you can outlast this one if he or she is terrible.

As a result of all of this going on in the background—some of which you may have been unaware of, frankly—you get lulled into sticking it out year after year. It isn’t until the pain gets too great that you begin to think, “There must be something better for me to do than this.” And the good news there is.

Any teacher can change career direction by using knowledge of the job search process. Understanding the job search process leads to a successful job or career change.

In fact, teachers have may options that don’t include teaching, but most teachers don’t know what their options are, and even if they did, they don’t know how to position themselves to make the change they desire. They haven’t ever managed a traditional job search before, and job hunting for teaching positions is a very different proposition from job hunting in the corporate or nonprofit world.

If you don’t know how to market your transferable skills, you may be in trouble before you even begin your job search.

So, what is a teacher who is suffering from low morale turned to teacher burnout to do? How do you begin to make a transition from a teaching career into another career path? Well, the answer is simple even though the process isn’t necessarily easy. The first thing you have to do is make a decision. Is it time to stay or go? Only you can make that decision for yourself. No one can gauge your level of unhappiness and dissatisfaction with your current circumstances but you. I believe that also means, however, that you can’t blame anyone else for what you decide to do. If you succumb to the pressure of family and friends who tell you how easy you have it because you “only work 9 months a year” (Ha!) and you convince yourself that you have it okay even though you are miserable 90% of the time, you only have yourself to thank or to blame as the case may be.

If you decide to tackle your burnout in a proactive manner, however, a number of different outcomes could come from it.

First, you may decide after looking at your options that maybe you are more satisfied than you thought. That happened for me around year nine. I was unhappy. I was working a second job to make ends meet, and I thought there must be a better way. I went to a career counselor and after learning that one of the things I could do would be to stock grocery stores with paper items for a third less than what I was making as a teacher, I decided to reassess. I now don’t believe that that would have been my only option, but I didn’t know what I didn’t know. So, I decided to stay where I was and go for my first Master’s degree. If I was going to stay, I decided to maximize my earnings, and at the time, not only did my district pay for my graduate courses, but there was a significant bump in salary once I finished my degree.

At another point in my career, I realized I was unhappy in my building. My principal was only a so-so leader, and there were other members of the staff who were so negative and disparaging of one another and their students that I realized my morale was suffering. I asked for a transfer and was lucky enough to get it. I say I was lucky because I know that for some, getting transferred from one building to another is sometimes problematic. But is an option, nevertheless, and one that might warrant investigating. Additionally, transferring from one district to another might make a difference. I had one client who did that, and it makes a huge difference in her attitude about teaching. She is much happier today than she was when I first met her.

If staying indefinitely is just not an option. However, it is incumbent upon you to explore your options which are more than you might think. I won’t kid you, though. Depending on what you decide you want to do, there may be a need to go back to school to get additional training.

The good news is that you will have a feeling of renewed energy as you undertake meaningful steps to get you out of your current state of misery and toward a new career that is full of possibility.

Many teachers make the transition from teaching into other fields of endeavor. From sales to marketing, technical writing to human resources. In my case, I became an entrepreneur. I took my skills and combined them with my passions, and I reinvented and retooled myself completely inside of 3 years. If I can do it, you can do.


skills and passions

Entrepreneurship is not a route I would recommend to everyone, but the fact is that if you have an idea, and you are willing to work it, with the online possibilities that are available to you, you could offer your products or programs through the Internet to a market that encompasses the world. I have coached individuals from Egypt, Nigeria, Ireland, Spain, and France as well as Canada and most of the 50 states. If you are willing to think big, big things can happen.

Changing career direction isn’t easy, and it isn’t for wimps.

You have to be committed to it, and you have to be willing to make some initial sacrifices to experience the long term pay off. You may need help to get your job search off the ground. Would you know where to start a job search? Do you know about the need for a new type of resume that is sleeker and more concise than the resume you probably already have? Do you know about the Applicant Tracking System (ATS)? Do you know the number one mistake people make when writing a cover letter? Do you have a LinkedIn profile of which you are proud, or are you embarrassed about the fact that you haven’t got a profile yet? Do you know what to do to prepare for an interview that will result in a job offer? All of these are the moving parts of a traditional job search, and I haven’t even mentioned the need to be aware of your personal and online brand.

The question is should you stay or should you go?


Photo by Shutterstock

If you are ready to make a change but don’t know where to start, you are not alone. Many of my clients came to me not knowing where to begin, and in some instances, they weren’t sure what it was that they wanted in the first place. They just knew they weren’t happy with their current circumstances.

You don’t know what you don’t know right now. Is it time to stay or go? Only you can answer that question, but if you are entertaining the question at all, it is time for you to take charge of your life and your career and do something proactive to change your current status. Every day spent in a job that you no longer love is another day wasted.

Another Teacher Resigns Over Low Pay and Lack of Respect

Another teacher–this time a National Board Certified Teacher with 13 years of experience–resigns because she can’t pay her bills on the low salary she was earning in North Carolina. She is tired of trying to make ends meet, and she is really tired of the disrespect being offered to teachers in NC, not to mention the fact that teaching is no longer fun, given the over-emphasis on testing and reliance on data. See the interview and read her letter of resignation which she addressed to the Governor of North Carolina along with others here.

Another Teacher Quits in Frustration

custom_stack_of_books_11960On March 23, Valerie Strauss of the Washington Post offered another article that caught my attention and then ignited my interest and finally touched my heart on a deep level. She offered the perspective of a Massachusetts kindergarten teacher who is, in my opinion, both a “teacher in distress” and a “teacher in transition.” After 25 years of teaching kindergarten, Susan Sluyter has decided she has had enough. She knows in her heart and soul that the obsession with data that is driving our school systems of today, thanks to wrong headed initiatives and generally bad education policy, is not serving children, and she just can’t participate in the farce any longer. Below you can see her letter of resignation. We have clearly lost another dedicated teacher because of these poorly thought through initiatives. When will the administrators and policy makers hear us? When more teachers like Suzi Sluyter make their voices heard. At least, that is what I believe. I don’t want to believe that it is too late…but I do fear that time is running out. More teachers need to find their voices and speak up…not just for themselves and the damage that has been done to our profession but for the children who are not being served by this current data obsessed system.

My favorite line from Ms. Sluyter’s letter is here:

“The overall effect of these federal and state sponsored programs is the corrosion of teacher moral, the demeaning of teacher authority, a move away from collaborating with teachers, and the creation of an overwhelming and developmentally inappropriate burden imposed on our children.”

The entire letter is worth reading, however as is the entire article.

Please feel free to share widely. I know that this letter will resonate with every teacher (especially the ones who remember what it was like to teach before No Child Left Behind).

Here is Ms. Sluyter’s letter in its entirety.

February 12, 2014

I am writing today to let you know that I am resigning my position as PreK and Kindergarten teacher in the Cambridge Public Schools.  It is with deep sadness that I have reached this decision, as I have loved my job, my school community, and the families and amazing and dedicated faculty I have been connected with throughout the district for the past eighteen years.  I have always seen myself as a public school teacher, and fully intended to work until retirement in the public school system.  Further, I am the product of public schools, and my son attended Cambridge Public Schools from PreK through Grade 12.  I am and always have been a firm believer in quality public education.

In this disturbing era of testing and data collection in the public schools, I have seen my career transformed into a job that no longer fits my understanding of how children learn and what a teacher ought to do in the classroom to build a healthy, safe, developmentally appropriate environment for learning for each of our children.  I have experienced, over the past few years, the same mandates that all teachers in the district have experienced.   I have watched as my job requirements swung away from a focus on the children, their individual learning styles, emotional needs, and their individual families, interests and strengths to a focus on testing, assessing, and scoring young children, thereby ramping up the academic demands and pressures on them.  Each year, I have been required to spend more time attending classes and workshops to learn about new academic demands that smack of 1st and 2nd grade, instead of Kindergarten and PreK.  I have needed to schedule and attend more and more meetings about increasingly extreme behaviors and emotional needs of children in my classroom; I recognize many of these behaviors as children shouting out to the adults in their world, “I can’t do this!  Look at me!  Know me!  Help me!  See me!”  I have changed my practice over the years to allow the necessary time and focus for all the demands coming down from above.  Each year there are more.  Each year I have had less and less time to teach the children I love in the way I know best—and in the way child development experts recommend.  I reached the place last year where I began to feel I was part of a broken system that was causing damage to those very children I was there to serve.

I was trying to survive in a community of colleagues who were struggling to do the same:  to adapt and survive, to continue to hold onto what we could, and to affirm what we believe to be quality teaching for an early childhood classroom.  I began to feel a deep sense of loss of integrity.  I felt my spirit, my passion as a teacher, slip away.  I felt anger rise inside me.  I felt I needed to survive by looking elsewhere and leaving the community I love so dearly.  I did not feel I was leaving my job.  I felt then and feel now that my job left me.

It is with deep love and a broken heart that I write this letter.


Suzi Sluyter

Sharing from Mercedes Schneider’s EduBlog

Mercedes Schneider is a teacher who has also been a school counselor, college professor, statistician and researcher. She is currently living in and blogging from Louisiana. She is frequently featured in Diane Ravitch’s blog, and I read her posts with admiration and attention because I know she has done her homework

Dr. Scheider recently (March 6) wrote a post entitled, “Equipping Florida Parents to Expose Jeb Bush’s Florida Eduction ‘Miracle.'” I would like to share it here because while it is specific to Florida in some respects, it can be used, I believe, by teachers and parents in many states across the country. It covers the “A-F School Letter Grades” scheme, for example, and it discusses charters and vouchers as well. I thought it might be useful to parents and teacher leaders around the country to have access to the information, so I am sharing it here. Enjoy and feel free to share wherever you see fit.

For All My Teacher Friends and Colleagues : There May Be Hope

Every morning, I peruse my email, clicking through the dozens (literally, dozens) of emails that have landed in my inbox overnight. I am always on the look out for things that I can share with me friends and colleagues. This morning, I hit upon a gold mine. If you have already seen this circulating on Anthony Cody’s blog, or through GFBrandenburg’s blog like I did, you will have already read this. For those who may not have seen it yet, I had to share. The words in this paragraph resonate so deeply with me that they bring tears to my eyes:

Our schools are being destroyed by politics, profit, greed and lies. Instead of evidence-based practices, money has become the engine of education policy, and our schools are being hijacked by politicians, non-educators and for-profit operators. Parents, teachers, citizens and community elders must arm ourselves with the best evidence and take back control of our children’s public education before it is too late. We all must work together to improve our public schools, not on the basis of profit or politics, but on the basis of evidence, and on the basis of love for America’s children.

The author of these words is James Meredith, the first black student to graduate from the University of Mississippi and a leader in the Civil Rights Movement of the 1960’s. To learn more about the American Child’s Education Bill of Rights, click here. I don’t know about you, but I want to read the book that James Meredith has co-written with William Doyle. The book is titled, A Mission from God:  A Memoir and a Challenge for America. I just ordered my copy.

Those who know me know that I love the notion of teachers “taking back their profession.” It is only too true that our schools have been “hijacked by politicians, non-educators and for-profit operators,” and they have been aided and abetted by our President who seems on one hand to truly care about children and teachers but then goes about showing his care and support in all the wrong ways. The policies that are currently in place are crushing our teachers and they are not doing our children any good either.

I sometimes despair that it is too late. but posts like this one and messages like Mr. Meredith’s give me hope. I hope it does the same for you. Additionally, Mr. Meredith has invited folks to comment on his bill of rights for children. To comment, you may follow Mr. Meredith on Facebook here.

There may be hope. Maybe it isn’t too late. That is my own hope. That is my prayer.

Possible Remedies for Teacher Burn Out

For the last couple of days, I have been following a thread of discussion on LinkedIn. The topic is teacher burn out and what might be done about it. Some solutions that were offered in one article were pretty superficial, I thought. The suggestions included offering a social time for teachers, for example, so they could get together and relax every once in a while. The other suggestions  were okay as far as they went, but they didn’t go nearly far enough in my opinion.

Teacher burnout is a serious issue and it is one that needs to be treated seriously although I don’t think enough people are truly paying attention to it. The fact is, however, that a growing number of teachers are feeling disillusioned about their chosen profession. What I hear on a regular basis from the teachers I work with is that they still love their kids, but they don’t feel like they are teaching anymore. They are, instead, delivering a canned curriculum and then administering test after test after blasted test. The fun has been sucked out of teaching and it is a sure bet the children they are teaching aren’t having much fun either.

I felt compelled to offer some thoughts on the thread and this is what I said:

“While it is certainly important that teachers be offered times to socialize and de-stress, feeding teachers’ souls is a lot more complicated. The teachers I know who are stressed and might be in danger of ‘eating their children’ are overburdened by paperwork, impossible demands at every level, lack of support from administrators and parents, debt because of low and stagnant salaries, feeling berated by people in power like the Secretary of Education who misses no opportunity to criticize teachers, and strangled by policies that have sucked absolutely all the fun out of teaching. I am also a life coach and a stress management coach whose niche are teacher leaders, teachers in distress and teachers in transition. When I conduct my workshops I always run into the same overall theme. Teachers feel overwhelmed, under appreciated and generally maligned. A social hour with colleagues will help to bond the colleagues together, but they need a lot more than TLC to help them feel better about themselves and their profession. They need to feel respected, and they need to be paid a professional salary while they are treated like professionals instead of widgets in the larger system that is doing no one any good…least of all the students they teach.”

I really believe that we are in the middle of a serious crisis with regard to public education in our country, and I fear for its future. Just today, I heard a snippet of an interview with Arne Duncan that pertained to what the President might say tonight in his State of the Union speech. One of the things I heard Secretary Duncan say was that we have been making progress…graduation rates are up and drop out rates are down…but he went on to say that the progress we have made isn’t enough and we “need to be changing faster.”

The trouble with Mr. Duncan’s premise is that he assumes that the changes we are currently making will get us where we need to go…that his policies and those coming out of his Department are actually doing anything other than creating more and more demoralization among teachers and students alike. Mr. Duncan loves to talk about our “failing schools” and how we are lying to our students when we tell them they are doing well. He also loves competition, so all of his major initiatives are based on the false notion that in order to promote public education and equity for all we need to make it about racing to the top and innovating around more and better tests instead of focusing on authentic teaching and learning.

If anyone were really serious about addressing teacher burn out…and I don’t think anyone really is serious about it or they would be doing something about it…they would stop telling teachers to “do more with less.” They would lighten up on the testing regimen because there are only so many tests that a child can take that they even have any meaning. They would forget the crazy notion that a child’s test score is a measure for whether or not to keep an otherwise effective teacher on the payroll. And they would stop fighting about Common Core and let a few states pilot it without drastic negative consequences for everyone involved in the meantime.

Public education is a value that I grew up believing in. I grew up poor, but because of educational opportunities and my belief that an education would provide me with an opportunity to thrive economically, I have thrived. As public school funding shrinks in favor of ideological arguments for choice, vouchers, and charters, I fear that the poorest children will get left behind and dropped through the cracks. We are at a real crossroads in this country, it seems to me. While the haves continue to thrive, the have nots are struggling. In the past, getting a solid education was the ticket to a better life. That seems to be growing less and less the case these days.

I know that teacher burn out is a real thing. I just don’t think that offering a social hour is the answer to it.

Arne Duncan Sticks His Foot In His Mouth–Again

I am no fan of Arne Duncan’s, and I never have been. I want to state that up front so that my bias is known to the reader from the get go. If you like Arne Duncan…if you think he has been a good spokesperson for teachers and students and if you think he is doing a fine job as the Secretary of Education for the United States, you may want to skip this post. I won’t mind, I promise. But if you are as offended by some of the things Mr. Duncan says about teachers in general and about public education in particular as I am, you may want to continue reading.

Mr. Duncan’s most recent egregious remark was made at a meeting of the state schools superintendents on Friday. He said that he found it “fascinating” that some of the opposition to the Common Core State Standards has come from “white suburban moms who–all of a sudden–their child isn’t as brilliant as they thought they were, and their school isn’t quite as good as they thought they were.” Yes, he really said that.

Of course, Arne Duncan’s disdain for public education in America is well known and documented. He has said many things along this line ever since he was appointed to the post of Secretary of Education by President Obama. His frame of reference is Chicago’s public schools, and he has yet to broaden his perspective to include the many successful schools that are operating all over the country every single day. He has measured his assessment of the nation’s schools based on that Chicago experience, and he is apparently sincerely convinced that most of the schools in this country are under par. Furthermore, he is of the opinion that a large percentage of America’s teachers are so bad that they should be fired immediately.

Duncan has an arrogant tendency to dismiss those who disagree with him, much the way we might swat at a fly or wave off a gnat that is bothersome but generally inconsequential. Indeed, Duncan’s tendency to dismiss detractors and critics was the subject of an article written by Dr. Patricia McGuire, President of Trinity Washington University in Washington, DC. in yesterday’s Huff Post. She commented that he “uses the word ‘silly’ a lot these days to describe people who have points of view that differ from his on the topic of education reform, both K-12 as well as higher education.”

I honestly haven’t decided yet how I feel about Common Core Standards. I know that the American Federation of Teachers (AFT) and the National Education Association (NEA) have offered support for them, and I think I understand why. And I wouldn’t go so far as to say that the standards are necessarily bad. I understand from some concerned critics of the standards that they are developmentally inappropriate, and if that is true, that is certainly worrisome and a legitimate source of concern. Having said that, I can appreciate the argument that having standards that have been adopted by every state might help students who move from place to place in this ever increasingly transient society. Students who move from California to Maine might benefit from having a more or less standardized curriculum so that a move doesn’t set them back because the curriculum in California is so markedly different from Maine’s curriculum, and vice versa. But I question the rush with which the standards are being implemented and the high stakes nature of the tests that continue to be tied not only to the standards but to teachers’ ability to get the students up to benchmarks which may or may not be realistic. Certainly the ultimate goal set for No Child Left Behind was not attainable. I wonder if it is possible that new goals being set by non-educators are similarly unrealistic and unattainable.

I don’t have an opinion about Common Core Standards, but I do have an opinion about Arne Duncan, and that is that he would do everyone involved a favor if he would step down and go to work for some for profit charter or testing corporation instead of abusing his current position the way he seems to be doing. A Secretary of Education should be a champion of public education. A Secretary of Education should be an exemplary educator. A Secretary of Education should have a deep understanding of the challenges that teachers face whether they are in our urban schools or our poorest rural schools. A Secretary of Education should believe that poverty is no excuse but not take away the resources that teachers need in order to work with the 16% of our students who live in poverty every day (20% of students under the age of 6 live in poverty). Mr. Duncan doesn’t get it, and unfortunately it doesn’t look like he is ever going to. He just continues to stick his foot in his mouth again and again. He continues to do more harm that good in the long run. I wish we had a champion as our Secretary of Education…but I guess I will just keep wishing for now.

My Thoughts on Diane Ravitch’s Reign of Error: The Hoax of the Privatization Movement and the Danger to America’s Public Schools

Once again, just as she did in her last book, The Death and Life of the Great American School System: How Testing and Choice are Undermining Education, Diane Ravitch has written clearly, plainly, and astutely about the problems facing public school education and public school educators today. She has not only researched her subject exhaustively, she demonstrates her knowledge of education history, her awareness of the many various public education detractors, and her understanding of the issues that lie at the heart of the current debate about which is better—public education or privatization of public schools giving free market full, unbridled reign.

Not only does she offer a clear and cogent outline of the various issues, problems, and dilemmas facing public educators today, she offers ideas for how to remedy those issues, problems, and dilemmas. And she has clearly struck a cord with some of the more notable “reformers” because they have been quick to criticize her work and to dismiss it out of hand. Indeed, just recently, Secretary of Education Arne Duncan referred to her and others who have the temerity to criticize Race to the Top and other initiatives with his thumbprints on them as “armchair pundits.” The irony, of course, of that criticism is that most of the “armchair pundits” are educators like myself—either still practicing or retired—who know more about the needs of children and what works and doesn’t work for public schools than Mr. Duncan could ever possibly know. But I digress.

 In Reign of Error, in Chapters 1-20 Dr. Ravitch lays out the problems facing public education today. She offers clear and indisputable research to support each and every one of her assertions. She has not “cooked” the research the way many reformers do these days. She is a researcher and she doesn’t have to distort the data to find the disturbing trends that she identifies here. Chapter 5, for example, is entitled, “The Facts about Test Scores;” Chapter 6’s title is “The Facts about the Achievement Gap;” and so on. She writes brilliantly about “The Facts About Teachers and Test Scores” in Chapter 11; and she even includes a chapter about the disturbing new trend toward virtual schools in Chapter 17, which is entitled, “Trouble in E-land.”

After methodically laying out all of the various issues, she then outlines her proposed solutions in Chapters 21-33, starting with “Solutions: Start Here” in Chapter 21. Unlike many education “experts,” she doesn’t just harp on the problems…she offers possible solutions based on research and her own understanding of what public education represents to our country as a democracy.

In Chapter 24, for example, she writes “The Essentials of a Good Education.” In Chapter 25, she writes about why “Class Size Matters for Teaching and Learning.” Each chapter offers a specific recommendation for how we might go about fixing the problems that face us. But never does she suggest that fixing those problems will be easy or cheap. Instead, she points out the fallacy in the thinking of those who seem to believe that education reform is easy OR can be delivered cheaply.

 Starting in the “Introduction,” Dr. Ravitch outlines what her book is intended to do which is to answer four questions:

             First, is American education in crisis? (Answer: Yes).

            Second, is American education failing and declining? (Answer:  No).

            Third, what is the evidence for reforms now being promoted by the federal government and adopted in many states? (Answer: None).

            Fourth, what should we do to improve our schools and the lives of children? (Answer:  Things that are complex and expensive starting with suspending the war on teachers and their unions; providing smaller class sizes; offering wraparound services; eliminating excessive testing; forgetting about merit pay as a panacea; etc., etc., etc.)

Dr. Ravitch then goes on to answer each and every of those questions using research and data from a variety of sources including NAEP, the U. S. Department of Commerce, the Census Bureau, the U. S. Department of Education, OECD, and numerous citations from individuals on both sides of the education debate, both the so-called “reformers” and the proponents of those who argue that we need to keep our public schools public.

I could go on and on, but you must be getting the drift by now. This is a must-read for any public school educator, for any parent who still cares about public schools and their role in the community, for the administrators who haven’t been so brainwashed that they have forgotten why they went into education in the first place, and many, many more. I cannot recommend this book more highly. If I were writing a review for Amazon (which I may do come to think of it) it would definitely get a five-star rating. For teacher leaders and parents who are concerned about what is happening to their communities because of the demise of the neighborhood school, I urge you to read it as soon as possible and start using the information inside its covers. More importantly, I urge you to get involved in the grassroots movement that has already started in some parts of the country. There are a number of groups around the nation where the push back has begun. Some of these groups have been founded by parents, some by students, and of course, teachers have started some. It isn’t too late, but time is ticking away. We need to start speaking out and organizing now.

I will offer the disclaimer that I am writing this review on the third day of the government shut down, and I have to admit that the idea that anything can be done legislatively to fix the problems we currently face, not just on the education front but in every aspect of our government, seems pretty dim at the moment. The prospect of getting legislators, Governors, and even the President to change their minds about these important issues seems to be pretty daunting, frankly. But I am reminded of the well-known quote by Margaret Mead:  “Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world; indeed, it’s the only thing that ever has.”

If we as educators, parents, administrators, and caring adults don’t take up this fight individually and collectively, the result will be a dual system of education that will serve no one, least of all our children and certainly not our country. I urge you start reading this important book today. You won’t be sorry you did.

How Much Further Can the Testing Madness Be Taken?

This morning while brushing my teeth and preparing for the day, I was listening to one of my favorite morning news shows. I don’t always turn on the news in the mornings. Generally, it only depresses me or makes me angry which is no way to start out a perfectly good day, but sometimes I can’t resist wanting to know what is going on in the world, so I turn on this one particular news station that I find to be the least offensive among my several choices.

As I was going about my morning routine preparing for the day, I heard yet another discussion of the antics of Miley Cyrus from the VMA awards Sunday night. I didn’t see the show, but the news outlets have made certain than even old fogeys like myself (I haven’t watched a VMA Awards show in like, ever) know about her performance which has alternately outraged and mystified those who did witness the spectacle live or saw it played again and again both on television and on the Internet. I still don’t know what “twerking” is, but I heard that term used quite a bit in the discussion. It was all over my head, so by the time they got to the bit of reporting that made me sit up and take notice, I had almost totally zoned out. I suddenly became alert, however, when I heard this piece of news: apparently a major testing firm has announced its intention to introduce a test (yes, another one) that can be administered to college students as they are about to graduate that will be predictive of what kind of worker or employee the test taker will be.

Yes, you heard me right. The testing company is contending that grade point averages, college transcripts, other college records, letters of recommendations, etc. are not predictive enough to allow a potential employer to determine if a potential candidate is a good bet as an employee or not. This test will confirm for the employer whether or not taking a risk on the candidate will pay off or not.

I was stunned momentarily as I considered the absurdity of the report…but then I sadly shook my head realizing that there will be people out there who think this is a fabulous idea! After all, we can reduce anything to a multiple choice test, right? WRONG! You can’t determine whether a person is a honest or moral or persistent or loyal with a multiple choice test. You also can’t tell whether the person is kind or not…whether she/he is a compassionate or caring person…because a test simply cannot measure one’s character or core values no matter how much a testing company would like to make you think it can measure such things. And let’s not forget that a young person starting out on a new job learns a lot about the world of work by actually having to perform on the job. But a test that can “predict” all of that is all a potential employer needs to make a hiring decision. It’s so wrong I can’t even seriously entertain the notion except that I am quite certain others are entertaining it very seriously.

I wonder how much longer we are going to put up with this testing madness? How many more millions of dollars are testing companies like this one going to bilk our citizens out of while we try to reduce the most complicated and complex matters like talent and courage and caring to a multiple choice test?

I for one am so over the whole fascination with high stakes testing I could scream, and I know that many of my teacher friends and colleagues feel the same way. Test scores have long outweighed any concern our society has for legitimate learning or deep understanding of any subject, much less a person’s creativity, talent or ability to innovate. We seem determined to try to test our way to “greatness” while we totally miss the much bigger picture. We simply won’t become a better nation by generating better test takers.

I long for the day when parents, the media, and the public at large wake up to that fact and start paying attention to the really important things like nurturing the whole child and encouraging young children to learn appropriately through play and exploration without having to decide how to eliminate the wrong answers in an attempt to get the “right” answer so that they can “measure up” against false measurements. Likewise, I long for the day when we measure the worth of an individual not by the score he/she managed on a standardized test but whether or not the individual can make a meaningful contribution to society that doesn’t involve bumping and grinding or “twerking” on national TV! We need young people to care about real issues including whether other countries are using chemical weapons on their own people not whether Miley Cyrus is a good girl gone bad. We need to get our priorities straight, and fast…but I wonder if it is not already too late.

It saddens me that we have reached the point that we have reached. We really need to get over our obsession with competition as the only route to success and with outrageous behavior as the only route to getting attention. It’s time to say, stop the madness already. But apparently–and sadly–we aren’t there yet because the news items this morning–both the Miley Cyrus discussion AND the testing idea were met with serious discussions instead of being tossed out as the absurdities that they are–both of them.

And just for the record, it’s time to stop talking so much about Miley and her performance Sunday night. We are just setting the stage for the next outrageous performance by showing so much interest in this one.